AI search · how to actually test it

Does ChatGPT recommend your business?

People now ask an assistant for a plumber the way they used to ask Google. You can check whether it names you, but almost everyone checks it wrong - and a wrong check is worse than no check, because it tells you something false with total confidence.

Scan your site free → Or book a call
Start with the trap

Asking once tells you nothing

An AI assistant does not give the same answer twice. Ask “who does HVAC in Patchogue” this morning and this afternoon and you will get two different lists, with different businesses in them, in a different order.

So “I asked ChatGPT and you weren’t there” is not a fact. It is one sample of something that moves. Anyone who tells you AI has never heard of your business based on a single question is either careless or selling you something, and you will find out which the moment you ask it yourself and your name comes up.

The fix is boring and it works: ask the same question several times, and write down a rate. Named 0 of 5. Named 2 of 5. Named 5 of 5. That is a fact about a repeatable test, and it survives you checking it yourself - which you should.

How to test it yourself in five minutes

The method

  1. Open any AI assistant. Start a brand-new chat each time - it remembers the conversation otherwise, and you’ll be testing its memory instead of its knowledge.
  2. Ask the question a customer would ask, not one with your name in it: “Who does gutter cleaning in Sayville NY?” Asking “do you know [your business]” tests something else entirely and always looks better than reality.
  3. Write down every business it names.
  4. Repeat at least four more times, new chat each time.
  5. Count. How many runs out of five named you? Which competitors came up every single time?

The number that matters is not really yours - it’s the one next to the competitor who came up in all five. That is the business the assistant treats as the safe answer in your town.

A real result

Named in 0 of 4, with 499 reviews

We ran this on a Long Island heating and cooling company. The business holds 4.9 stars across 499 reviews. By any normal measure it is the strongest reputation in its market.

0 / 4

Times it was named

Four runs, four fresh chats, the same question a customer would ask. Not once.

4 / 4

Two competitors

Named every single run. A third came up in three of four.

4.9★

Its actual rating

Across 499 reviews. Being genuinely good and being the answer are different problems.

That gap is the whole point. Reviews did not make this business the AI’s answer, and the businesses that were the answer are not four times better. Something else decided it.

What we honestly know, and what we don’t

This is new, and the industry around it is running well ahead of the evidence. So, plainly:

What seems to matter

Assistants lean heavily on what is already written about you in places they can read - your Google listing, directories, local press, forum threads, and your own site if it plainly states what you do and which towns you serve. Businesses that are easy to describe in one sentence tend to get named. A site that says “we serve Long Island” gives an assistant nothing to attach to a town.

What nobody can promise you

There is no submission form, no setting, and no agency with a switch. Anyone guaranteeing you a spot in an AI answer is describing something that does not exist. The same was true of Google in 2004, and the guarantees were lies then too.

Why it still matters

Because the list is shorter. A Google results page has ten links and a map. An assistant names three businesses and stops. Being fourth on Google is a bad day; being fourth in a list of three is not being there at all.

The honest first move

Before anything clever: make sure the basic, boring facts about your business are correct and consistent everywhere an assistant might read them. Same name, same phone, same towns, on your site and your Google listing. Most local businesses fail this, and it costs nothing to fix.

Then run the test again in a month and see whether the rate moved. That is the only feedback loop that exists right now, and it is the reason to write the number down the first time.

“I run a plumbing company and it never names me”

This is the form the question almost always arrives in - not as a theory about AI, but as one owner in one trade who checked and did not like the answer. The mechanics are the same in every trade. What differs is which source the assistant is leaning on when it decides who to name, and that is worth knowing, because it tells you where the work is.

Trades called in an emergency - plumbers, electricians, roofers, towing

Assistants lean hardest on the Google listing here, because it is the source with hours and a phone number attached. If your listing is missing service categories, or your hours are wrong, or your service area is a single pin rather than the towns you actually cover, you are difficult to recommend for an urgent request and you get skipped in favour of a business that is easier to describe.

Food - bakeries, delis, restaurants

This is the category where third-party writing matters most. Assistants repeat what local blogs, round-up articles and review sites have said, and a bakery with no mentions anywhere outside its own site is close to invisible no matter how good it is. One genuine local write-up moves this more than a year of posting.

Appointment trades - barbers, salons, med spas

The usual failure here is that everything about the business lives on Instagram, which assistants largely cannot read, and on a booking platform page that describes the platform more than it describes you. If the only readable text about your shop is your name and a phone number, there is nothing for an assistant to say about you.

Home services quoted per job - painters, landscapers, contractors

These get named when the towns are explicit. An assistant asked for a painter in a specific hamlet is looking for text that connects a business to that hamlet, and most contractor sites say “Long Island” or “Suffolk County” and nothing narrower. Listing the towns you actually work in, in words, is the single highest-value change in this group.

Auto - body shops, repair, detailing

Specialisation is what gets you named. Assistants handle “who does European car repair near Islip” far better than “who does car repair”, because the narrower question has fewer defensible answers. A shop that never states what it specialises in is competing to be one of three names out of every shop in the county.

None of that is a trick and none of it is fast. The common thread is mechanical: an assistant can only repeat what is written about you somewhere it can read. If the honest answer is that very little is written about you anywhere except your own homepage, then being unnamed is not a judgement on your work. It is a description of the record.

My trade, specifically

The pages below are written for one trade each, and they cover the same ground for ordinary search that this page covers for assistants.

Common questions

How do I check if ChatGPT recommends my business?

Open a brand-new chat and ask the question a customer would ask - 'who does gutter cleaning in Sayville NY' - not a question with your business name in it. Write down which businesses it names, then repeat at least four more times in fresh chats. Report the result as a rate, like 'named in 1 of 5 runs'. A single question proves nothing, because assistants do not give the same answer twice.

Why does ChatGPT name my competitor and not me?

Assistants lean on what is already written about a business in places they can read: the Google listing, directories, local coverage, and the business's own site. A competitor named in every run is usually easier to describe and more consistently documented across those sources, not necessarily better at the job. We tested a company with 4.9 stars across 499 reviews that was named in 0 of 4 runs while two competitors were named in 4 of 4.

Can I pay to appear in AI search results?

No. There is no submission form, no setting and no agency with a switch. Anyone guaranteeing placement in an AI answer is describing something that does not exist.

Do Google reviews make AI recommend my business?

Not on their own. The clearest case we have measured is a business with 499 reviews at 4.9 stars that was never named across four runs, while competitors with weaker reputations were named every time. Reviews matter for customers and for Maps; they are not the lever here.

Does AI search actually matter for a small local business?

The list is much shorter than a search results page. Google shows ten links and a map; an assistant tends to name about three businesses and stop. Being fourth on Google is a bad day. Being fourth in a list of three means you are not in the answer at all.

Is my business on ChatGPT?

There is no directory to be listed in, so nothing to be “on”. An assistant answers from what it can find about you elsewhere - your Google Business Profile, your own site, directories and reviews - and reassembles it each time it is asked. So the real question is not whether you are on it, but whether it names you when somebody asks for what you sell. Test that by asking as a customer would, five times in fresh chats, and recording how often you come up.

ChatGPT is not recommending my business. What am I doing wrong?

Usually nothing dramatic. The businesses that get named tend to have a complete, consistent trail: the same name, address and phone everywhere, a Google profile that is filled in rather than merely claimed, recent reviews, and a website that actually says what they do and where. If your details differ between your site, your listing and the directories, an assistant has no confident answer to give and names somebody whose story is consistent. Nobody can promise you a result, but a clean trail is the part you control.

How can I check what ChatGPT says about my business?

Ask it the way a customer would, not the way an owner would. Open a fresh chat, ask “who does your trade in your town”, and note which businesses it names. Do that at least five times in separate chats, because the answer changes between runs. Then ask it directly about your business by name and see whether what it says is actually correct - wrong hours and a dead phone number are more common than being missed entirely.

Do AI assistants recommend businesses?

They name them, which amounts to the same thing for you. Ask for a plumber in a specific town and you will usually get two or three businesses with a sentence about each. There is no paid placement and no way to submit yourself, which cuts both ways: you cannot buy your way in, and neither can the competitor with the bigger budget.

I run a small bakery. How do I get ChatGPT to recommend my business when people ask for bakeries near them?

Make yourself the easiest bakery in your town to describe. That means a Google Business Profile with the real hours, the category set properly, photographs that are recent, and reviews that mention what you actually sell. Then make sure your own site says the town name and the products in plain words rather than only in images. An assistant cannot name what it cannot read, and a lot of food businesses keep their entire menu inside a picture.

How often should I re-check?

Monthly is plenty, and always with the same question and the same number of runs, or the comparison means nothing. Write down the rate each time - that is the only feedback loop that currently exists.

Want this run on your business?

The free scan covers your site and your Google listing. If you want the AI test run properly on your business and your competitors, ask on a call - it takes a few minutes.

Run the free scan →